Benjamin Steakhouse New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Benjamin Steakhouse New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Benjamin Steakhouse New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Benjamin Steakhouse New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Benjamin Steakhouse New York
Benjamin Steakhouse New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
26 Reviews
0 Replys |
Abusive price of wines
The food was outstanding. We order the Porterhouse for 3 and it was incredible. However, they charged $30 for each glass of wine, only to find out that the bottle is only $20 (check yourself on google for Torres Celeste 2019). They charged 7 times the cost. Abusive, really. We ended up paying 280 in food and 210 in just average, crianza wine. 3 people.
Be the first to ReplyPerfect NY steakhouse
Great food, service and atmosphere describe Benjamin’s perfectly. We had a lovely dinner in the downstairs dining room. The service was phenomenal with someone always close by to tend to our needs but not too overbearing. We had the steak for two, steak fries and bacon appetizer. All meals were delicious and well prepared- but be aware that the bacon is very large. We were full before our steak even arrived, not a bad thing but just a word of advice. A great experience all around.
Be the first to ReplyFamily vacation
Excellent restaurant all around. Amazing food and great service. ! One of the top restaurants I visited during my stay in New York!
Be the first to ReplyAnniversary Steak Dinner
We chose to eat here to celebrate our 10 year anniversary. The food was delicious and the service was great too. We both had the French Onion Soup to start and the n shared a Steak for 2 with the spinach and mushroom sides and a bottle of wine. After our meal we were brought a complimentary drink each for our anniversary. We really enjoyed our meal and would like to thank you for your hospitality and a 5 star experience.
Be the first to ReplySteakhouse Anniversary dinner in NY
First time in New York and decided to have a steak and found this restaurant, food was good only French onion soup wasn’t up to our taste, since we mentioned to Manager he was kind to don’t change us, it got bit loud as it was busy, we had a porterhouse steak with few sides and wine, absolutely loved it, steak was huge, we had to take it with us, they sent us anniversary dessert plate which we enjoyed it well! Thank you, we will be back on our next visit!
Be the first to ReplyTrue Gem
Outstanding On All Cylinders. Johnny & His Team Are True Gems & The Food Is Always On Point, went this past Monday sat alone @ the bar an had a nice meal with a few glasses of wine. “G” the bartender was AMAZING as always he made sure i was well taken care of. Thank you guys for a truly amazing dinner an thanks for the great hospitality
Be the first to ReplySteak destination when visiting the Big Apple!
Definitely dine at Benjamin Steakhouse if you want a warm and inviting night out! The filet was beautifully prepared and delicious!
Be the first to ReplyI highly recommend
Sober setting, attentive service and the best lamb chops grilled to perfection. A pure delight. I highly recommend. I forgot, the homemade cheese cake, to die for.
Be the first to ReplyOverpriced
Overpriced, staff not attentive. Lovely ambiance food ok. Had better in midtown. Great location just off Maddison. Be mindful of the tipping.
Be the first to Replynot to be repeated
We had high expectations for this restaurant, but this was really disappointing. The oysters we ordered were tasteless. The steak for two was tasty, but not in relation to the price. The waiter puts drinks on the table again without asking.
Be the first to ReplySteakhouse at its best
We visit this place when we are in the city and love it. The place was full but the service was still amazing! They have a week menu that was very convenient and included what we usually order as options. Absolutely recommend!
Be the first to ReplyBad
Came, extremly noisy, food was ok minus. Wine was served nearly after we had finished our meal. Go somewhere else.
Be the first to ReplyOutstanding steak
Excellent steak and seafood in surf ’n turf. The kitchen gave us complimentary dessert wine since it was our honeymoon. The second time here and for me, this is the best steakhouse. Superb service! Next time have to get the tomahawk.
Be the first to ReplyGreat steakhouse in NYC
Perfect steak and excellent service! Steak for 4 was perfectly cooked, great charred crust! Fantastic wine list and knowledgeable friendly service completed an excellent NYC steak experience! Will return!
Be the first to ReplyVery Good Old School Steakhouse
This upscale steakhouse did not disappoint on our last night in NYC. The restaurant is a large space with tables draped with white tablecloths. It’s very old school. Our main server was Jet. Friendly, engaging and attentive. Benjamin’s wine list is extensive. We chose a bottle of red Zinfandel knowing we’d have beef. We ordered the tomahawk steak, and we chose not to have an appetizer. It was a good thing, too, because the steak was huge! We did choose two sides to share to go along with our steak, the creamless creamed spinach and Benjamin’s potatoes. When the food arrived, Jet had a couple other staff members with him to serve the food in unison. Quite the presentation! The plates were piping hot to keep the food hot. The tomahawk steak was cooked to perfection, medium rare on the rare side. The creamed spinach was creamy good, and the Benjamin’s potatoes were over the top. The potatoes were cubed crispy but tender potatoes topped with crumbled blue cheese. So delicious. At the end of the meal, Jet brought us two complimentary glasses of port wine. So very sweet and such a nice touch! I highly recommend the steakhouse for its impeccable service and quality food…and the great wine list!
Be the first to ReplyPeter Luger without having to travel to Brooklyn
The porterhouse is thick, tasty, and impressive, albeit priced like the skyscrapers of Manhattan - very high. The side of broccoli was excellent - crisp and crunchy. The creme brulee is a nice ending, with an accompanying side bowl of cream to make sure you have enough calories!
Be the first to ReplyThe Best Traditional Steakhouse anywhere!
Whenever I am in New York I make sure to visit Benjamins. I prefer the one on 41st Street - far more traditional with a much better atmosphere. The one on 40th Street is more of a fine dining experience - no harm in that - food equally great, however the 41st Street one buzzes with atmosphere. Sitting at the bar, watching the bar staff mix cocktails, chatting to the customers, and serving excellent food is, for me, better than anyway Broadway Show! Sitting there is like being immersed in years of history. It is a classic place to go. Historic!
Be the first to ReplyOutstanding
My husband loves steak so chose to come here while we were in New York for a birthday treat. The steak was amazing and our server Ricky couldn’t do enough for us and was so helpful with recommendations and making sure our meal was perfect. The only downside was we couldn’t eat it all! Had this been a resteraunt at home I would have definitely asked for a box to take home the left overs! Would highly recommend and will return if in New York again
Be the first to ReplyGreat food and out of this world service
We arrived early with our party of 5 and they immediately accommodated us at a lovely round table near the bar. Our server, Andrea, was also a bartender and she took a macabre of us, both food and drink. The cocktails were superb and she accommodated our teenage niece with a mock tail …Food was excellent, all the appetizers were perfect, calamari, caprese, especially. Filets were cooked to order…creamy spinach, house potatoes, and lobster Mac and cheese were great sides to share. Cheese cake and chocolate mouse pie…yummy! But honestly, the biggest attraction was our wonderful server, Andrea!
Be the first to ReplyWorth the visit
It was a very charming experience. The interior was very suitable for a stately steakhouse. The food didnt disappoint.
Be the first to Replynever disappointed
For the past dozen years my husband and I travel from Texas to NYC just before Christmas. We celebrate Christmas eve with a fabulous dinner at Benjamin Steakhouse. The shrimp cocktail is always fresh; the ceasar salad tasty; the vegetables wonderful and the Porterhouse for 2 is cooked to perfection!!
Our only disappointment is that they have not opened a restaurant in the north Dallas area.
Our waiter, Johnny G. was very polite and attentive!
Poor service
We had dinner reservations for 10:30pm checked in at 1025 pm and where told right at the door that we had to hurry because the kitchen was closing . Why would they let you book a table for 10:30 and hurry you this way . Unacceptable
Be the first to ReplyDon’t Overstay Your Visit
We planned a dinner at Benjamin’s Steakhouse. Our reservation was at 7:00. We were seated immediately. We ordered drinks. They appeared quickly as did our waiter who took our dinner order. Our appetizer arrived in minutes, and before we put our forks down, our entree and side dish appeared. In under an hour, we could have been done, but for the cappuccino I ordered. As to the meal itself- the Lump Crab Meat appetizer was wonderful and more than sufficient for two. We ordered the Porterhouse Steak for Two. It was good, but nothing special. It hardly could stand up to other Steakhouses we have enjoyed (Capital Grill and Gibson’s- no competition here). The hash brown potatoes were mediocre at best. Along with the cappuccino we ordered a slice of Key Lime pie (no dessert menu or list was offered by the waiter- we saw it at the next table). Trader Joe’s, we’ll stick with your pie..
On top of it all, the room was so noisy it was hard to talk to one another (considering it was a table for two, that’s saying something).
Needless to say, I’ll stick with my old reliables in Chicago.
Great Steak in NY
Great steak and great service. Sides were large and delicious. Steak for three was truly plenty for all of us. The restaurant has a nice ok'd world charm.
Be the first to ReplyGreat Steakhouse in the Heart of NYC
My wife and I dined at Benjamin Steakhouse on Wednesday, August 4, 2021, and ordered off the Restaurant Week menu. We had an excellent dinner and the service was exceptional. We both ordered the Caesar salad and I had the filet mignon and she had the salmon. The salad came out within a few minutes of us ordering. Both my steak and her salmon were cooked to perfection. And I should add they bring out a bread basket of freshly baked rolls and assorted other goodies that were delicious too. For dessert, I had the chocolate mousse cake and she had the cheesecake. Both were excellent as well. Our server Johny was very attentive to our needs and made it a nice dining experience. It is a fine dining restaurant and it is on the pricey side but when you order off the Restaurant Week menu, it is only $39 per person and that is why I rated the Value so high. You are getting a first class meal at a very affordable price. I have been to Benjamin before and think it is a great restaurant but you can't go wrong going during Restaurant Week.
Be the first to Reply