Appointment Trader
Search 
Sign In
Developers
How It Works
Get into Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City! 🔥
Chat
Buyer Protection
Option to Cancel
Alias Check-In
Upload Your Reservation Now
Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City Reviews
We found the food to be delicious.
Service excellent. I would even rate this higher but we did have an issue that would chose not to complain about. We both got the surf and turf. I wanted my steak medium rare. My husband asked for his to be slightly pink. When the waiter brought it o
Worse experience and waste of money ever
Worse experience ever. Spent $300.00 essentially for a turd with a $300.00 bow. The apps weren’t horrible. Ordered strip steak medium. Got bone in, which is an up charge, still mooing with a lot of inedible fat. Sent back. Then got medium to medium
Food is delicious and services is amazing .
Great place to go on a date or with family.
Go somewhere else
Had dinner reservations tonight. No problem there. Four adults- two ordered the mashed potatoes- they were great. Also two of the filet mignon. Both were decent although a little tough. We asked for steak sauce as they hadn’t brought it to the tabl
Very expensive.
Had the Branzino and it was chock full of tiny bones. Very annoying to eat and I didn't find it seasoned very well. Big disappointment as I have had this at other restaurants and the experience was much better. Two others joined me for dinner, w
The restaurant itself is beautiful.
Excellent use of space, the tables are far apart and not on top of each other. The tables along the windows have a nice view of the boardwalk. We had a good view of the ferris wheel. The table bread was cut into 4 small rolls, and was reminiscent of
Celebrating my Birthday with hubby for a romantic dinner.
They had a great menu selection and the atmosphere was top notch and extremely professional! Everything we ordered was delicious and special! Service was excellent but I wish they would have considered a complimentary glass of champagne to celebrate
Outstanding! 5 star food and service.
I ate here twice during my stay at Hardrock Casino. Yes, it was that good. We're big fans of Helld Kitchen at Caesar's, but let me tell you, this place has them beat. Everything from the steak, to shrimp cocktail, mussels and the star of th
We went there for my 60th birthday celebration.
We had a reservation for 6 and they had a table for 5. When they had to add a place setting, they acted like they were really being put out. We waited way too long for our food, and the fillet I ordered was terrible. I couldn't eat it. My husba
This place had great surf and turf.
Huge restaurant and some good views and people watching opportunities. Was very impressed.
The food here was incredible.
I got the large rib eye that fed two (I forgot the name of it on the menu) but it was excellent. Cooked to perfection. The crust tasted fresh off the grill and the inside was nice and tender. The lobster Mac and broccolini was delicious. And so was t
I was here having dinner last night with family.
Ordered old fashioned, They gave me the drink with small ice cubes and told me need to request the big rock. I ordered their most expensive ribeye in medium rare and came well done. My wife ordered lobster bisque was forgot to put in maybe or just
Awful
1. The online menu is not same so was disappointed in choices 2 We both had lobster bisque soup which tasted good. But unable finish the rest of our meals due to sour stomach both of us. I then went into bathroom to vomit. 3 this was my 4 time at AC
DINNER AT THE BAR....
Stopped in for dinner and decided to sit at the bar. We decided on the 2lb lobster, baked potato and seared scallops to share. First 2 seared scallops $20.00, we asked for the lobster to be cleaned ~~ not the best... baked potato was alright. Ve
Thanks for Feeding Me!
Work schedule a little wacky lately, felt the need to recharge my batteries, so an overnight stay at Hard Rock in AC was necessary. With just one dinner to plan, I had to return to Council for their lobster pot. Lucky me (at the slots too) Karlar
Very good with a few minor issues!
Overall, our experience here was very good. The service was excellent as was the room ambience. I started with a gin martini which was well prepared. The downside to this drink was the price at $24! I've order this same martini all over AC and n
Not Nearly the Best
A lovely but noisy dining room with many men in baseball caps. Service was adequate, steaks were delivered overdone and had to be refired to the requested medium. Two classic sides, creamed spinach and potatoes au gratin, were over cheesed so as to o
Come for the meat, stay for Rob
Was in Atlantic City to see a local comedian (Bob Levy). A quick drink at the bar led to an amazing evening because of your bartender, Rob S. He was charming and provided excellent service. We bonded over our mutual love of dogs and butterflies. Than
This Restaurant Earns Its Stars.
We had a wonderful meal. From appetizer through entree everything was perfectly prepared, spiced and presented. The Filet Minion was succulent and tender. The Skirt Steak was flavorful but could have been more tender. The white fish dip was excellent
Food tasted great... until after dinner... bring your immodium
We were looking forward to a fun weekend at the Hard Rock and a nice dinner at Council Oak to kick off our night. A party of 12 of us had dinner reservations on Friday December 6 at 6 pm. We were lucky enough to be seated in the glass room. The fo
The only thing that was good about the visit was Alberto
The only thing that was good about the visit was Alberto the waiter. We were sat behind a wall between sets of windows before it became crowded. When we asked to be sat by a window, we were told we would have to go back in line. We were ignored by ma
Excellent restaurant! Our go to place when we are in AC.
Food is absolutely delicious and the wait staff is so professional and courteous. A must visit dinner place for anyone who visits Atlantic City. Birthdays, Anniversaries anything special occasion this is a great place for it.
We were here for my BF's birthday.
I'm thinking it is possible maybe the chef is having a bad day. We both like our steaks medium rare, and mine came out as medium to medium well. So it was taken back and got another medium rare. when we ordered our food we were told it'll be about 30
One of the best places in Atlantic City is council oak.
If you get been I recommend it. I been to the Tampa Bay Area and they have it in the hard rock there. It is truly one of many places you need to stop in. This is their seafood version of the one in Florida. The one in Tampa is more steakhouse. I lov
I just scrolled through recent reviews that had quite bad
I just scrolled through recent reviews that had quite bad experiences here but luckily that didn't happen to us 2 nights ago. Had a 6:30 reservation and felt that the staff at the entrance weren't noticeably customer-focused or friendly. The manager
Overpriced for what you get.
Apps were good - the octopus , crab cake and short rib were good. Steak was mediocre and sides just as underwhelming. What is it about the restaurants in Hard rock ? None of the food ever comes out hot - including the food here. And the bill was ve
Had the opportunity to try Counsel Oak again after a
Had the opportunity to try Counsel Oak again after a previous not so great experience. Everything was outstanding from the bone in ribeye to the salads and sides. Bread is exceptional as well, server was amazing. So glad I tried them again, will d
My husband and I like to enjoy a cocktail at a fancy bar
My husband and I like to enjoy a cocktail at a fancy bar before or after dinner. We decided to try the Council Oak Steaks & Seafood. They had live music and bar was pretty. I ordered a lemon drop martini and my husband had a Hendricks and tonic.
Heather was our server and she was great ! She was really
Heather was our server and she was great ! She was really nice and attentive. The other servers were also attentive and kept refilling our drinks. For the apps, we got the beef tartare, octopus, and short rib. The apps took awhile to come and they w
My husband and I ate there Sunday nite 1/29/2024.
First let me say the lounge singer was fabulous but it's all downhill after that. Drinks came pretty much on time. I ordered a wedge salad and Kobe beef meatballs. The salad was good except for the dressing I'm not sure what was on it. I think pic
Terrible host situation, the hosts act like they're the
Terrible host situation, the hosts act like they're the doormen at Vegas' hottest club, so rude and disrespectful everyone trying to get a table for dinner without a reservation. The waitstaff was great though even though the food was pretty bad. I'v
Very good, consistent , and dependable
I go to Council Oaks once a month while visiting the Hard Rock. The food is dependably very good, and the service exceptional. It is a little pricey, but well worth it for an enjoyable dinner out. I usually get the 10 oz filet mignon , which is perf
Verygood but just not matching the price in some dishes.
A little too salty. Steak was very good but not an 89.00 steak by any means. Potatoes great octopus appetizer very good. One tenticle and priced very high. Asparagus great. Brusselsprouts great, scallops were delicious, service was excellent.
Wonderful steaks!!…
Great service and atmosphere. We both had fillet. Done perfectly! Asparagus and the au Gratin potatoes both fantastic! Béarnaise Sauce was white with little flecks, not good, no flavor, Chef needs to know: white wine vinegar, white wine, butter,
Disappointing
I had really high hopes for this restaurant but unfortunately it sucked. I'm not sure it they were having an off night but at the prices they charge I won't be going back in case it's always this bad. I was expecting a meal as good as Morton's or R
Outstanding Filet Mignon
Pretty quiet in the restaurant. I was invited as i was part of a conference as I was invited. The service was very good but more importantly the steak was outstanding. I had the smallest meat offered the filet and it was outstanding. Perfectly se
DINNER AT THE BAR....
Stopped in Saturday night for dinner and decided to sit at the bar. Our service was so-so. We ordered the iceberg wedge to share, and than went with a baked potato and the 10oz filet to share. Food was enough for the 2 of us and our meal was very
Favorite birthday brunch!
Our family of 16 guest were treated like loyalty! Our beautiful hotess, Betty Mchugh ,greeted us with style and grace. Right away Champagne, coffee ,Bloody Marys and what ever we wanted to drink ws brought to us and never empty. The buffet is over t
Customer service fail
I want to start by admitting that I made a mistake. Somehow I booked an Open Table reservation for this same restaurant in a different state. When we arrived the hostess figured out my error, but said said that she would get us in at 5pm. (We had
Birthday Dinner for My Sweetheart
We decided to come to Council Oak to celebrate my sweetheart's birthday. The service and food are incredible. Our waiter was Alberto. He was friendly and quite attentive. We started our meal with crab cakes and New England Clam Chowder. For the main
Stay away.
Basically dog food. Obviously prepared by DIY cooks. Steak was dry and chewy tuna was also dry and tough. I don’t even know how you can screw up food like this so badly. Quite simply, the food is not treated properly and it shows. More expensive th
Fabulous food and service.
The ribeye cut like butter and was perfectly seasoned. The scallops were cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend even if they are quite pricey.
Food was just okay the service was attentive and the
Food was just okay the service was attentive and the ambiance was nice. I would recommend if you likr
My wife and I picked Council Oaks as the special place to
My wife and I picked Council Oaks as the special place to dine as we celebrated our first night in Atlantic City.Are we ever happy we did as we loved it! Everything was outstanding.Start with the service. Hostess Betty was lovely. Ashley,who took us
Council Oak Rocks!!
I’ve been away from the Atlantic City scene due to illness for a few months. Stopped by Council Oak for dinner on the weekend. It’s like coming home again. I was greeted warmly by James who is like a brother (one that you like!). He was just so
Service, pricing and preparation has significantly changed
This used to be our favorite place in AC, but the service, pricing and preparation has significantly changed. We won't be back again for a while. Hopefully it improves. Restaurant was nearly empty but the gentleman at the front desk wouldn't seat
This used to be our favorite place in AC, but the service ,
This used to be our favorite place in AC, but the service , pricing and preparation has significantly changed. We won't be back again for a while. Hopefully it improves. Restaurant was nearly empty but the gentleman at the front desk wouldn't seat u
Excellent Service and Very Good Food
I have come to believe that excellent servers work at the best restaurants, because they can. So when the restaurant has a knowledgeable, skillful staff of servers, the rest typically falls into place. This restaurant is an example of the aforement
We had dinner here last weekend.
They accommodated us even though we didn't have a reservation. We sat in a quiet room which was super nice. I have to mention the chairs were so beyond comfortable for a restaurant. Our server was so attentive. We started out with the calamari
I've been to steakhouses all over the country and this one
I've been to steakhouses all over the country and this one was quite good. One thing I have to commend them on is the service. Absolutely perfect. Vert attentive, polite, and fun to chat with. Now to the food. Our table had a smattering of appetizers
Connect with users posting reservations for Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City
AppointmentTrader is a community-driven platform where users can exchange their reservations or leverage their personal relationships with Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City. Buyers can make informed decisions using automated seller ratings, which reflect past transactions and reliability.
Each posting on AppointmentTrader shows you which user submitted it and along with that provides a trackrecord of that user which indicates how much experience
the user has and how many percent of their transactions resulted in them issuing a refund.
If there is no user posting that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
Let's say Peter has a great morning and decides to take his three friends to Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City at 6 PM the same day.
He checks the restaurant's website and sees that no reservations are available. He then looks at the Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City page on AppointmentTrader, but finds that there are no user postings either.
That's where the community-driven bid process comes in.
Peter can place a bid on AppointmentTrader, which serves as a reward for any community member who chooses to work on securing the reservation. AT then notifies experienced users who may be able to help.
Step-by-Step Process
1.) Setting a Reward (Bid)
* AppointmentTrader uses historical data to recommend a reasonable reward amount for securing a reservation - let's say $100.
* Peter really wants to go, so he increases the bid (or reward) to $200.
* At this stage, the reservation does not exist yet.
2.) A Community User Picks Up the Bid
* ElaborateHouse74, an experienced AT user, has a strong track record of successfully securing reservations and low refund requests, they receive a notification about Peter's bid.
* ElaborateHouse74 picks up the bid, meaning they will now work on securing the reservation.
* Peter can now talk to ElaborateHouse74 for any questions Peter may have as ElaborateHouse74 user fills the bid.
3.) Finding the Reservation
* ElaborateHouse74 now uses their connections at Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City to secure the table.
* If they successfully get the 6 PM table for four, Peter receives a confirmation that the reservation has been secured.
* If ElaborateHouse74 fails to secure the reservation, the bid is returned to the pool so another user can try.
4.) Payment & Protection
* Once the reservation is secured, ElaborateHouse74 receives the $200 reward which is credited to ElaborateHouse74's AT balance, where users manage their own funds and can withdraw via available payout options such as bank transfer, PayPal, or Zelle.
* Peter can now enjoy the dinner with his friends at Council Oak Steaks & Seafood Atlantic City!
* As with all transactions on AT, disputes and no-show fees are handled through the platform's community-driven resolution system. Users with a strong track record are incentivized to fulfill bids successfully, and community members can report issues to maintain trust in the marketplace.
