Gallaghers Steakhouse New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Gallaghers Steakhouse New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Gallaghers Steakhouse New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Gallaghers Steakhouse New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Gallaghers Steakhouse New York
Booked 4 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #2 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 4 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #1 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 4 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #3 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #23 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #9 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #5 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #16 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #196 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #19 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #4 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #47 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Gallaghers Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #163 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Gallaghers Steakhouse New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
39 Reviews
0 Replys |
Best meal of our holiday
My husband and I ate here yesterday. It was really special! The food and the ambience in the restaurant is so lovely. George our excellent waiter made some great recommendations with our menu. We opted for Oysters which came with all the trimmings. We then had the Porterhouse Steak which was so delicious and cooked to perfection. We enjoyed our visit so much, we have booked again for today and we can’t wait. A special thanks to George for looking after us so well!
Be the first to ReplyGreat lunch course price
This was our second visit to this restaurant as our first time was back in 2019. We had a great experience back then and decided to go back. Lunch special was the perfect meal, portion, and price. If I remember correctly the price was same as it was in 2019, which we really appreciate since everything else in the world are more expensive since then. Service was great and food was pretty good. My steak was good but it was just not as great as I remembered. It was still cooked as I ordered (medium rare) and almost full of flavors. Clam chowder soup was delicious and so as my sorbet. I still recommend this place and you can't beat that lunch course price in NYC.
Be the first to ReplyGallaghers 52nd street
Another lucky find. Originally a speakeasy frequented by the stage stars of the thirties. The staff were absolute best and the filet mignon perfect.
Be the first to ReplyGreat dinner!
I ordered the wedge salad with a crabcake and broccoli. The food was absolutely delicious and the service was exceptional.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing steak experience
We visited on our trip to NYC. This was recommended to us by a few people. We booked ahead, which would be best to do, we went on a Saturday night and was really busy. We got taken in and seated straight away, one cocktail and one juice for us. We got bread as we waited. We both had a sirloin steak and shared fries, mushrooms and onion. The steak came with steak sauce. The fries were huge so we just shared one as wouldn’t have managed one each. You could see the steaks being cooked behind us also. Staff were very kind and attentive and always made sure we were ok and if we needed anything else. Waiters kept topping up our water also. The steak was lovely, very tasty and cooked to how we like, sides were lovely also. Very very filling, couldn’t manage to eat it all as was a large portion, sad we were unable to finish as was so good. No room for dessert, however they looked really nice
Be the first to ReplyGreat food - great price
We chose this venue based on its lunchtime special: three courses for $32, which I had read about beforehand. Upon arrival, we were immediately captivated by the restaurant's delightful atmosphere and ambiance. We were served by a wonderful, friendly waiter, whose name I unfortunately did not get. He was especially attentive to our 10-year-old, who opted for a side dish of mac & cheese instead of the full three-course meal. As our lunch menu came with dessert our waiter kindly offered him a choice of ice cream or a brownie to complete his lunch experience—a small gesture that truly enhanced our visit. The food from start to finish was fantastic, and everyones steak was cooked perfectly. From the first bite to the last, the food was outstanding, and everyone's steak was cooked to perfection. After a disappointing steak experience earlier in the week at another establishment, it was a relief to enjoy a flawlessly prepared meal. A place to visit - especially at lunchtime.
Be the first to ReplyExcellence epitomised. Ambiance, Service and Food ;-)
We had been recommended to Gallaghers by a very dear friend in NYC and we looked forward to experiencing the recommendation. Definitely not disappointed by everything that Gallaghers stands for - excellent steaks, terrific ambiance and the most personable staff imaginable. We were fortunate to be served by Shane Milligan - a truly professional master of his craft and a terrific asset to the establishment. A dining experience is as much about ambiance and service as its is about the meal served. The restaurant exudes the charm of bygone times - atmospheric and evocative ;-) Gallaghers wins - hands down - on all aspects of a delightful experience so many thanks to all that contributed to our evening - especially Shane!!!!!!
Be the first to ReplyBest meal we had in NY
Best meal we had in NY, had the lunchtime special menu - $29 for 3 courses and was absolutely delicious. Service amazing , venue so classic, truly a lovely place. Drinks and sides are a bit pricey but def worth it - would go back in a heartbeat.
Be the first to ReplyFirst time visiting NYC
It was mine and my partners first time visiting NCY a couple of weeks ago. After seeing a lot of videos on Tik Tok about this place we thought to give it a try, it DID NOT DISAPPOINT. As we knew this restaurant was a little pricey we thought to ‘splash out’ on our last night. The restaurant it’s self has a chilled vibe to it, lovely secure inside and you can even see into the kitchen and your food being made by the chefs. The staff are super friendly from the minute you walk in to the minute you leave. Excellent service, the waiters were coming over as soon as our drinks were empty and topping up our water before it could get to low. The staff work super hard and are so friendly! Me and my partner had the ‘NY sirloin’ (I think that’s what it’s called) and this steak alone filled up most of the plate, if not entirely. The food was cooked to perfection and as we asked for. What a lovely way to end out last night in the best city in the world. We will definitely be back on our next trip - thank you!!!!
Be the first to ReplyGood steaks. A bit pricey.
I'm not disappointed in the restaurant. It was good. But fell short of 5 stars in my opinion. It's very high priced and the steaks are good, but not great. The atmosphere and service are excellent. My son was given the wrong order, (sirloin instead of filet). He ate it anyway and enjoyed it. But we both walked away with the same opinion of the steaks. The sides were excellent (Brussels and mushrooms).
Be the first to ReplyBuyer Beware, Gallagher’s in Las Vegas!
Excellent food, wonderful time until told we had to move on. There were 7 in our party and after drinks, appetizers, main meal , dessert and after dinner drinks ( not finished yet), told our “time” was up and to move out. We also purchased the pictures. Anyone who had been to Gallagher’s in New York New York, Las Vegas knows their prices so being told to “move on” after the bill was paid was completely disrespectful to your customer. So, if you are going to sit back and enjoy your meal, etc., don’t bother going to Gallagher’s in New York New York, Las Vegas. The creepy guy in the Fedora is told to tell you when your “time is up”! Buyer beware!
Be the first to ReplyGreat Steak
We visited Sunday 12th March for lunch. I had the lunch special and paid a supplement to have the filet mignon. My wife ate from the a la carte menu. Service for friendly and efficient. The food was excellent, my steak was cooked to perfection. One note, if you order a side, they are large and suitable for sharing….see the photo below of a side (of table) of mushrooms. If I had one criticism, and this is a minor one for me, the restraint does feel crowded especially if you are sitting on one of the tables (the booths seem fine). This did not detract from my experience but may be worth considering asking for a table preference if the meal is something special. Would I return? Yes, most definately.
Be the first to ReplyGood lunch special
We did the lunch special for $30. We got the filet. It was cooked well. The environment is nice. This is a more upscale restaurant but we were casually dressed which was fine. Overall was very good, nothing super impressive but for the price a good deal. Would recommend.
Be the first to ReplyRude waiters
decided to eat here after a recommendation Lovely steak although food snd drinks overpriced waiters rushed the meal start to finish and not happy about the tip telling us your tip don’t cut it What the hell you tip what you want not what they demand how rude he was his service or manner was nothing exceptional Trying to embarrass you in front of other dinners is totally unacceptable A tip should be accepted with gratuity not demanded and told to give more Change your attitude to tips and stop acting like a spoilt child your place is not that special
Be the first to ReplyDecent steakhouse but not on par with others
Came into the city to see a friend and wanted to go to a nice steakhouse. I enjoyed the atmosphere at Gallaghers (dry age room as you walk in is a nice touch) but the food should be much better for what you pay for. We had clams casino for an appetizer and they were great. They provide bread and butter with flake salt on top. These two items were the highlight of the meal, which is unacceptable for a famous steakhouse. I ordered the ribsteak, which is a ribeye, that was good but not great. We got mac and cheese and creamed spinach, accidentally, for sides. The mac and cheese was recommended by the waiter but resembled the likes I would find at a school cafeteria (stay away). When we ordered the sides, we said we wanted broccoli. The waiter misheard us and said we wanted the creamed spinach inquisitively. We corrected him and told him again we wanted broccoli. I guess he didn't hear us the second time and still brought us creamed spinach. The creamed spinach was not bad and definitely a lot better than the mac and cheese. I wouldn't come back here and waste my money. Plenty of other steakhouses in this area. If you are in Brooklyn, I can recommend Amber Steak house and their bone-in ribeye.
Be the first to ReplyFirst Time but Not the Last
My husband and I went to Gallagher's for lunch on Saturday before catching a show. I don't understand bad reviews of this restaurant. From the moment we walked in we were greeted by a lovely man and a young woman who immediately showed us to our table even though we were about 15 minutes early. We were seated in a corner table side by side. We both chose the lunch special which was delicious and very reasonably priced. I had the sliced filet mignon and my husband had the salmon. He said that it was quite possibly the best salmon he has ever had. The cheesecake was delicious! I also had the potato and leek soup, which was served chilled. Everything was so good! No complaints here! Sometimes I think the bad reviews are more about the person doing the review than the meal itself. Just my opinion. We are anxious to try other dishes next time we are in NYC. Kudos to our server Mario. Excellent service! Loved his cologne too!
Be the first to ReplyImpeccable Service & Dining Experience
Immediately upon entering, there is a feeling of being transported back in time or on a movie set. The walls are covered in signed photos of actors, musicians, politicians, and athletes. You know wherever you are seated that someone famous has also dined there. Our server has been working at this restaurant for 48 years! Wow! I loved watching many of the servers in his same age bracket giving advice to some of the younger guys. My husband and son ordered and devoured the filet mignon. The sides are family style and can be shared. We ordered way too much food and did not come close to finishing any of the sides between the three of us. mashed potatoes, green beans, creamed spinach, and brussel sprouts… all delicious But, the CHEESECAKE…. Save room for this!!!! O! M! G! It is perfection. So smooth and creamy. Absolute perfection. The food, service, atmosphere, and overall experience was 10/10. 🤩 We will be back!
Be the first to ReplyGood but not perfect
Cool atmosphere and nice menu, lobster and shrimp dumplings were delicious. Our porterhouse was just ok. The strip side was fatty, not rendered well and the filet side over cooked. We were surprised that no one checked on us between the food delivery and clearing the table. The sides were good. Water wasn’t filled unless we asked and we had to pour our own wine. Overall nice night-but for the price expected a higher level of service and a perfectly cooked steak.
Be the first to ReplyTop of the Top
When I’m in NYC, I’m used to go to this restaurant since 1988. So, I saw the “history “ of Gallagher’s in the last 30 years. It’s a matter of fact that, now, this iconic restaurant is a top in the top ranking! Food quality, service, atmosphere are unforgettable. I had a dinner with my family few days ago and I can confirm what I have written before. The top experience was even reinforced by the superbe service made by our waiter Giorgio and the super-kindness of Lorenz (Manager). Hope to come back soon!
Be the first to ReplyMost authentic steak house in NYC!
This was my second time at Gallaghers, several years apart and it was better than ever!! The service was super, with personalised, friendly chat from the waiter, but not intrusive. We had a great table at the back overlooking the kitchen (worth booking ahead and requesting) and loved every minute. The menu is fantastic and the steak was superb! The sides were huge so no need to order more than one between two unless you are seriously hungry, but again the choice was brilliant. The old style feel to the restaurant is really authentic and the atmosphere superb, it's like stepping back in time in NYC and we loved it. 5Stars all round and somewhere I now recommend to anyone I know visiting NYC.
Be the first to ReplyThe best steak ever!
Service was excellent, servers were so friendly and very helpful when we were ordering. Very friendly staff. Wonderful atmosphere. Cannot recommend this restaurant enough. The place to visit if you like a very good steak.if we ever get to go to New York again this would be our first stop.
Be the first to ReplyGreat steaks!
This was just a great meal & a great steak. The onion rings were also delicious. The service got a little slow at the end & we had to wait a long time to get our check but I will definitely be back.
Be the first to ReplyBest steak I’ve ever eaten!
We visited this restaurant on recommendation from a family friend.
It was absolutely sensational. The welcome, the table, the staff - and the food was out of this world. My steak just melted in the mouth. Will definitely visit here again when next in town!
Jimmy is amazing!!!
The restaurant has a great atmosphere, warm, friendly, charming , the food is fantastic, we have a marvelous porterhouse, and a tender Carpaccio.
But over the top is Jimmy… he take care us in a lovely way and he make our night unforgettable!
Reputation goes before it!
Fell on this restaurant, just off Time Square. Superb! Staff, ambiance and food! Amazing. Note, sides are huge, definitely for sharing!
Be the first to Reply