AppointmentTrader FAQ - Mary's Fish Camp New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Mary's Fish Camp New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Mary's Fish Camp New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Mary's Fish Camp New York Reviews from The Last Year
A friend and I recently had a meal at Mary's Fish Camp.
We were excited to go. Everything was just fine. The prices were very high. But we shared a few starter items so it wasn't too bad. I mean, I'm sure they have a delicious lobster roll, but for $46? Seems a little bit excessive. Although everything these days is so outrageously expensive I suppose it just the way of the world. At least the New York City world. Anyway, the negative part of our experience was the service. They took our order in a timely manner. The food all came out in a timely manner, but once we had eaten, the service vanished. They didn't clear our plates for a very long time, although they sat empty for about 10 minutes on our table. And then, after they cleared us, no one ever came back to check and see if we wanted dessert or anything else! I had wanted one of their lovely desserts, but after a while, I became very annoyed/disappointed by the lack of attention, I just waved down waitress and asked for the check. I also want to add, that the restaurant was not busy. It was a Thursday night. That's the reason for my three star review. The food was fine, and the service was not so good. With the prices they're charging, they could do better. #disappointed
Fish is terribly over cooked and over a charred grill that
Fish is terribly over cooked and over a charred grill that leaves the skin of your fish bitter to add insult. We've given it a few tries to no avail. We are not seafood snobs, but we are from Spain and know fish. If you're looking for good fish and sea food find another place. If you like mayo covered heart stopping fried seafood, charred bone dry farmed whole fish while you sit elbow to elbow drinking a 90 dollar bottle of good Albariño in a children's water glass. This is your place.
My mother took me out to Mary's for my birthday this year
My mother took me out to Mary's for my birthday this year after it was recommended to her by an old friend from the village. The salad, beignets, lobster roll and udon were all delicious and came out quick and hot. The fries were awesome. The service was friendly and professional and the place was so fun and cozy, we loved the posters. We will definitely be making this a tradition!
Had a wonderful time here with my family.
Excellent service and incredible food. It's the best lobster roll in the city. Maybe the universe. If you like seafood, do your self a favor and go eat at Mary's. Boutique oysters by the way and also- the whole fish (grilled or fried) is divine. One of the last standing family run joints in the village- and easily my favorite.
Amazing food and terrific service.
You can't get better seafood and the salads and desserts are great too. Very nice time in a relaxed atmosphere.
Supremely underrated place in the city.
Got a really easy reservation on a Saturday for lunch. Great date spot! The lobster roll was so juicy too. Loved it
I took my girlfriend here for her birthday (she's a big fan
I took my girlfriend here for her birthday (she's a big fan of seafood, me less so...) and we were absolutely blown away by the atmosphere, the service and the quality of the food. We have varying levels of experience when it comes to oysters but agreed these were the best we'd ever had. She got the pozole and I got the cod sandwich with fries (and the fries had no business being this good at a place where fish is the speciality) and we ended up splitting both. The ingredients were top notch and the execution of both entrees felt special. We've eaten plenty of stews and fish sandwiches in our lives but none quite like this! Definitely a balance of tastes that would be hard to replicate at home. We almost didn't get dessert but caved when we saw a different table get a hot fudge sundae- the same thing about the fries go for the dessert. The kitchen's attention detail in all aspects of the meal did not go unnoticed by us. Everything we ate was A+ across the board. There's a flavor here that can't be beat - and I'm not talking about the food - the atmosphere is groovy and intimate. Most of the other places in the neighborhood are also great but have that 'restaurant group' quality that can feel rather impersonal so it was a real breath of fresh air to eat a fantastic meal somewhere that felt this intimate and homegrown. The music that was playing was great, everyone who worked there was accommodating and the meal was beyond delicious. We'd heard about Mary's from a friend's very enthusiastic recommendation and I have no doubt that we will be going back and recommending this place as zealously as it was recommended to us!
we had a 6:30 rez , which they confirmed several times.
On the rez, they make it VERY CLEAR, they hold the rez for 10 mins. we get there ...there are 7 empty tables. they tell us our table will be ready soon. after a while, I ask: which is our table? they point to 2 people taking up 2 tables and said they are having dessert. as we waited and waited and waited, I said to the host, they are both on their phones. why dont you seat us at an empty table ? oh no, they are reserved. i said, we have a reservation...she shrugs and says would you like to order at the bar? we said NO & left. Ridiculous! the entrees are $54! we went across the street without a rez, and had a lovely evening, no thanks to Mary's BullShit Camp. PEARL was so much better!!!
Delicious seafood.
Mussels are a must. Lobster roll is an NYC contender for the best. Cozy spot in a great neighborhood with attentive service. Long bar with lots of stools or come with a group. Love this place.
Some very good fried oysters and clams with a huge helping
Some very good fried oysters and clams with a huge helping of bad attitude by the server behind the register by the front door. Us: "We'd like a drink and a snack." Him: "We don't serve cocktails here - just wine and beer." Last I checked, wine and beer qualified as "a drink." How about welcoming us in instead of trying to convince us to go? $57 later - two small pours of house white and an even smaller portion of seafood. The menu looks great and the place is cute, but between the bad service, high prices and stingy portions, we won't be back.
Waitstaff ruined the experience
Amazing food - as always. But this time an unsettling experience - an exchange initiated by a member of the wait staff toward a customer at another table. She confronted them rather loudly (and rudely) about the amount of the tip they were leaving. In essence she was publicly shaming the customer so the whole restaurant could hear it. (From the customer’s reaction -it did look like there was an honest mistake made with the cash given to her.) Understand the frustrations of wait staff - but not the way you handle this in the service industry. It should have been done in a much more discreet and quieter manner.
Amazing service, outstanding food
Happened across this place by chance, thankfully,had a fantastic warm welcome from the host and the service was just amazing, ordered the IPA which was a really good drink, and oysters to start ,Oysters were so tasty!!!! Had the special which was sea bass and it was cooked to perfection I will certainly come back next time I’m in NYC and I’d recommend this place without a doubt
Gooooood lobster rolls
We were a group of 3 people, ordered oysters for appetizer - not the best. We also ordered fish and chips, fish tacos, and lobster roll. Fries are amazing, they were so thin but still chewy. lobster roll was amazing, other plates were regular. The fish in fish tacos are the same as the fish and chips. Wine came in a water glass and at the price of 21 USD. Get the lobster roll and nothing more.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mary's Fish Camp New York
AppointmentTrader FAQ
Questions and Answers around the platform.
52,776 People following
928 Questions
626 Answers |
Ask a question about AT |
Tune into NBC News - Top Story Tonight 7:40p ET |
Let’s go. Get more people placing bids!
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits? |
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment |
Transferring reservations is not supported in AT. Why not just use the name in the AT screenshot?
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ |
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee |
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil |
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it? |
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid? |
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted. |
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from? |
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered? |
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
How do I sell my when my related reservation’s restaurant does not exist on AT?
How do I sell my when my related reservation’s restaurant does not exist on AT? Its listed as a hotel, but it also has a restaurant under the same name ‘Chiltern Firehouse’ in London
Give the best answerNewbie sellers— how fast do your reservations sell?
I have some reservations coming up tomorrow that have gotten lots of views but haven’t sold yet. I haven’t made a sale yet since I just joined this week. I keep lowering the price, but am worried they won’t sell. How long did it take you to sell your first reservations? And did you have success being reimbursed by AT for no-show or cancellation fees? Just looking for a little reassurance. Thanks!
Give the best answerPayment taken , reservation not received
I just bought a reservation, the money was taken from my Apple Cash. The reservation however does not show up in my portfolio
Give the best answeremail address for my acc
I left my employer and need to change my email address for my account. How do I do this?
Give the best answerSeller with the Polo Bar reservation on 5/17 for 4 people
I am interested if you are willing to negotiate. Post on my wall if/when you see this.
Give the best answerZ’Z Club
I have reservations!
Give the best answerMoney in trader points disappeared
Hi everyone- I have made a couple of sales now and I am extremely disappointed.
I had money to transfer over that became available in my "traderpoints" section that has disappeared completely. its gone.
has this happened to anyone?
also- when I click the money pending, im unable to click my pending deposit account
so upsetting
How to list a Nobu Malibu reservation
Hi, I have a reservation to Nobu Malibu, but since they don't do text or e-mail confirmations I haven't been able to get my reservation posted. I have posted a screen shot of the phone conversation on the listing, but it keeps getting rejected. If anyone has an idea how I can get it approved that would be much appreciated, thanks!
Give the best answerHolding a bid
What does it mean to hold a bid? and how do you do that?
Give the best answerNeed to change the date but its being worked on
How do I modify?! I am no longer traveljng that day but since the reservations opened up today someone grabbed it and is working on it for a month from now and i cant figure out how to and if i can modify the date!
Give the best answerReservation Name
Ok - Newbie question here - I just purchased a reservation as a gift. How do I know/change the name on the reservation?
Give the best answerRome
Can anyone help with a reservation for Aroma (vis a vis from the Colosseum) in Rome?
6 PAX 21.5 19-20:00
Thank you!
Can’t wait to last minute?!
How do you set a timeline for getting your bid accepted? I can’t wait till the actual time I want to go. I want to know at least eight hours ahead of time. How do you do that?
Give the best answerHow do I choose the restaurants to make a reservation for?
I can’t find restaurants with high performance or like what’s the most popular restaurant or what is in short supply? Any advice?
Give the best answerConcierge change fulfillment time
I posted a request for a reservation this Thursday between 6:30 and 8 pm and initially the potential seller said it would be fulfilled by today. Now they changed it that they will only fulfill it by 5pm that same day. Basically I would have an hour and a half to get to the restaurant. Is this allowed?
Give the best answer@bravehand53
Hi. Is today Cote reservation for 4people at 8:00pm - 9:00pm for indoors or outdoors?
Give the best answer2 Ppl 5pm san Sabino res
Anyone want?
Give the best answerApp
This app is a catfish and overrun by people programming “bots” and algorithms. It makes it frustrating for someone not well versed in this to have any movement. I thought this would be a fun side hustle, but unfortunately it’s become like any other “side hustle”. Don’t waste your time with this crap. Not a question, just a suggestion. Also don’t pay these fake “gurus” hundreds of dollars to teach you. Might as well sign up for a software class. 😕
Give the best answerMy reservation review keeps getting rejected
I have a reservation for Kasama Chicago on Mother’s Day at 7:30 pm to sell but it keeps getting rejected
Give the best answermore then 15 submissions at the same time
can i get more then 15 submissions at the same time and how do i make this happen
Give the best answerWrong resy
I bought a resy for Tatiana By Kwami and when i unlocked seller lied it was for a different restaurant
Give the best answerSold reservation
What do I do with the reservation after I sell it? Do I need to notify the restaurant?
Give the best answerPaid $75 for name change that didn’t happen and cannot get anyone to reply
I paid $75 for a name change for a reservation. I bought last week that name change did not happen when I got to the restaurant they did not have my name. Luckily they took me anyway because I had the name on the reservation. AppointmentTrader owes me $75 and I can’t get anyone to reply, how do I claim my $75
Give the best answerPostpaid?
One of the reservations I put up for sale is notated “postpaid” whereas none of my others make any mention. What gives??
Give the best answer