Appointment Trader
Search 
Sign In
Developers
How It Works
Get into Rails Steakhouse Montville! 🔥
Chat
Buyer Protection
Option to Cancel
Alias Check-In
Upload Your Reservation Now
8 users watching
Rails Steakhouse Montville Reviews
Under staffed and sloppy is basically what comes to mind
Under staffed and sloppy is basically what comes to mind for our experience last night at Rails.We used to enjoy going here and hadn't been in a while so we grabbed some last minute reservations and drove the 30 minutes together there just to be
Great Braised Short Rib and Service
We went to Rails after seeing great reviews about their braised short rib — and it did not disappoint! Absolutely delicious and worth the visit. For my appetizer, I had the goat cheese and beet salad. While flavorful, I was hoping for more beets s
Rails Steakhouse now there's a place that looks like it
Rails Steakhouse now there's a place that looks like it stepped right out of some elegant dream where the decor whispers "class" without shouting it from the rooftops. Our server, Janelle, was nothing short of fantastic the kind of p
Amazing.
Food quality is superb. Service is on point. And the vibe is great no matter where you sit. Although the speakeasy is our fav!
Came here for date night prices were reasonable for a
Came here for date night prices were reasonable for a steakhouse atmosphere was amazing. Food was phenomenal and after dinner manager gave us a tour and the secret downstairs... Recommend for special occasions or a nice dinner.
Words can hardly do justice to how exceptional this
Words can hardly do justice to how exceptional this restaurant is. We visited to celebrate a birthday, and the staff went out of their way to accommodate us with a quiet booth on the speakeasy floor--an atmospheric space that truly transports you to
Food was excellevt
1st birthday party was amazing! Service was exceptional and so friendly! The food was absolutely delicious!! Would definitely have a party here!
Service was excellent from start to finish.
Highly recommend booking a reservation in their speakeasy for a more intimate and unique dining experience. The oysters were fresh, the bacon appetizer was outstanding, and the steak selections were top-notch. Only downside--the sides came out room t
I recently had my daughter's baby shower in the Mosiac Room.
The food was excellent. The service was amazing. I would recommend Rails if you are having an event. Pat Leone made my daughter's day a success.
Food, service, ambiance 100%, we celebrated my son's
Food, service, ambiance 100%, we celebrated my son's birthday! All was perfect. I really loved it
Rails is one of my favorite steakhouses in the area.
The food is always excellent, the vibes are on point and they have a great cocktail list. The portions are typically a good size to being leftovers home. We typically only stop in for birthday dinners / special occasions, etc, but came on Sunday beca
I went with a friend to have dinner at one of our favorite
I went with a friend to have dinner at one of our favorite places. We sat outside on a beautiful night and I had ourselves the delicious rolls they brought along with some raw oysters and then I went for the ribeye with brussels sprouts. It was absol
As Constructive Criticism - Do Better!
Rails is a high-end steakhouse in suburban New Jersey and within it's category... I'd give it a solid four stars. HOWEVER... if ownership seeks to break through to being truly top-flight... management needs to show far more attention to d
We enjoyed this place very much.
The pizza was delicious, Dinka on point and food was very good. Our waitress was so nice and friendly definitely would go back.
Underwhelming
My first time to Rails. Lots of “ pregame hype “. Good but no wow factor. It’s a big restaurant. Lacks intimacy. Don’t go for a special romantic occasion. More like an Aspen ski lodge vibe. Drinks just ok. ( I sent back my martini twice!) Foo
Poor service and management
I planned a dinner here for 10 guys in the Speakeasy for my Husbands 50th birthday. This is a group that goes to a Steakhouse dinner at least once or twice a year together throughout the NYC and Jersey area. This was sub pare to say the least. H
It's not just the great food
I visited Rails Steakhouse in November with my spouse and quite possibly had the best burger of our lives. There was a mix-up with our payment, which took some time to resolve, but after the holidays and a couple of follow-up calls, Mike from Rails p
Always a good experience
Always a great experience. Food and service was excellent. Expect to pay a pretty penny. We spent over $550 for a party of 3.
Superb fine dining in a relaxed atmosphere
My wife and I had dinner here in early January around 7:15 pm. We were stunned that on a Tuesday night the place was packed. We soon discovered why. The ambiance here is nice, particularly in the Library room where we managed to get a table near the
What a dissapointment
We were invited to go to a birthday dinner there. While the food and atmosphere was pleasant we got charged for the whole bill. We split the bill between 3 couple, however we got charged for the full amount. We have called several times, have spoken
SOLID
There is ALWAYS something going on at RAILS especially in the summer with their specials . . . Over the past few weeks we have visited to indulge in them . . . First it was the clam bake which was a total total home run with a 1 1/2 lb lobster as the
Food and service could not have been better.
We were celebrating my wife's half century birthday. Officially very vintage .. The seafood tower was amazing. We asked to swap clams to oysters. Plenty of lobster, crab, and shrimp to share. The aged steaks were just as good as the top rated NYC
My work friends and I celebrated our last day of school
My work friends and I celebrated our last day of school last evening at Rails and we were blown away! We started off at the speak easy and were greeted by our wonderful waitress, Carolynn! Her upbeat, personable (yet professional) personality added t
Four of us went there on a Saturday night.
We were upstairs and stopped at the bar for a cocktails. Beautiful place, spacious and well appointed. I'm a bar guy and me and the missus enjoy, when it's just the two of eating and drinking at the bar. The service was not great, ma6be it is too big
Came for a brunch private event on the second floor and
Came for a brunch private event on the second floor and everything was wonderful. The brunch options are pretty varied, but the winners for everyone by far were the short rib Mac and cheese and the butter scotch French toast bites. Big fans! Staff wa
We went to Rails to celebrate our 30th Anniversary and was
We went to Rails to celebrate our 30th Anniversary and was extremely disappointed. Our waitress seemed very annoyed and not very attentive toward us.To the point that we just left our paid check and walked out. We have been to Rails in the past and
The ambience, service a d food were equally amazing.
Loved how the Caesar came with anchovy filets on the side. All our steaks were superb -- especially the Tomahawk that three of us shared.
Great service even better food and delicious drinks.
I do recommend making a reservation, as the restaurant is very busy! The setting in the main dining area is slightly overcrowded by customers and staff trying to get around the packed rooms but overall great experience
Food was excellent.
If you do not look rich you will be treated as sub par by wait staff. We were told "we ordered enough sides" after questioning where our side was that the server vocally tried to sell us on (apparently they sold out and they forgot to tell
Our waiter was very hospitable and attentive.
The food was good, though not a lot of options on their menu. My chicken was tender but the micro greens layered looked old and brown (or maybe they were just overheated and dried up?) Their wine bottle prices are reasonable. The ambiance at night wa
First I want to state that the food and service far
First I want to state that the food and service far exceeded our expectations. I made a reservation at Rails on May 27 for June 8 at 5:45 for our anniversary which I noted on the reservation. There was traffic, so we called the restaurant to tell t
Great food and drinks from Prohibition Days!
Clearly thta is a year for us to attend stripmall restaurants for great mels and service. Rails strekhouse has bow been open fof 10 years. It is a unigue straehouse - not part of a chain. There is top level service that always puts the custimer f
Another bad experience!
I purposely waited a year before I went back because I had a bad experience. Last night my daughter and I went and ordered the 2-12 ounce filets. Hers was pretty good mine was 12 ounces of FAT. The manager came over and he agreed. I didn’t or
Dinner, Drinks, Celebration, & The Speak Easy
We had a wonderful dinner, drinks, and birthday celebration with 10 friends at Rails recently in the Speak Easy downstairs. From the hosts to the bartenders to our server, Karoline, to other staff, everyone was fabulous, friendly, and professional. O
Best steaks in North NJ!
Our new favorite steakhouse! Steaks were incredibly good- especially the honey bourbon ribeye. Sides and desserts were perfect compliments. All topped off by our amazing server - shout out to Nick T!
Birthday Dinner
I’ve been wanting to visit since it first opened. I’m glad my family took me here for my special day. I had filet mignon, lobster appetizer, cocktails and cake! So delish and what a beautiful place.
Third Time Is NOT a Charm.
I went with my family a year ago (4/2023) and we were so impressed. Food was fabulous, service was friendly.. worth the money. I was there twice recently. One time with friends and second time with my husband. Both times the food was good not fab
perfect place
perfect place excelent food went many times will not be disappointed highly recommended service was great prices are very good beautiful place very clean
Memorable birthday dinner!
What a great birthday dinner! Was here with family. I wanted a good steak from a good non-chain steakhouse and Rails fit the bill. I hadn't been in at least 6 years so it was time for another visit. Our server, Lennon, greeted us warmly and told us t
Beautiful space, service is sometimes good, sometimes not.
My biggest issue is the food which is good, but never amazing
Sea bass was excellent, pizza looked great and Wells's the
Sea bass was excellent, pizza looked great and Wells's the burgers! Apps are Hugh and very good
Sooooo good!!! Food amazing! Drinks quick and tasty!!!
Sooooo good!!! Food amazing! Drinks quick and tasty!!! Steak was like floating on a cloud! Tender flavorful and sooo much! Totally gonna come here again before heading back to capital grille. Just more fun upbeat atmosphere! We dined in the speakeasy
First visit, Great place to relax and unwind with delicious
First visit, Great place to relax and unwind with delicious attractions and an awesome menu as well. The atmosphere is open with high ceilings and airy aroma lit candle lighting, rustic Natural wood accents, clean modern washroom. Open bar area as we
We loved the Speak Easy Room in the lower floor.
Good wine and cocktails selection. Onion / Cauliflower soups and Shrip/Avocado salad were good. ( wish soups were more temperature hot though ) Cowboy steak (Bone in Rib Eye ) and Chilean Sea Buss were pretty good
Amazing food and atmosphere.
The food is excellent and you can get anything from a burger, Pizza, pasta,fish or, filet mignon. Save Room for amazing Desserts too. There's a great drink menu and amazing wine list too. The architecture and interior reminds me of a Colorado chal
This is a wonderful local steakhouse with stunning decor,
This is a wonderful local steakhouse with stunning decor, excellent service and amazing steaks. The waitress was very knowledgeable and answered all our questions and made really good suggestions. She saw we have a toddler and she quickly went to gra
Great steakhouse.
Food cooked and seasoned perfectly, although we were originally given the wrong dish...twice.
I can't understand how the place has a good rating.
People must get caught up in the atmosphere. It's a beautiful place with good service but the food is decent at best. The steak is never good. I've been here about six times with groups of people and have never been impressed
This was our second visit to Rails Steakhouse, and we very
This was our second visit to Rails Steakhouse, and we very much enjoyed it. We do not eat a lot of steak, so when we do, we want it to be really good. Rails fits this nicely. Great atmosphere, very good steak, and we were very satisfied with the ser
Disappointing
First time I have been. Waitress recommended tomahawk steak for four of us. Definitely not enough. We have two London broil size slices each. It’s a matter of taste but did not like blue cheese augrain potatoes. Will try one More like one in the fu
Connect with users posting reservations for Rails Steakhouse Montville
AppointmentTrader is a community-driven platform where users can exchange their reservations or leverage their personal relationships with Rails Steakhouse Montville. Buyers can make informed decisions using automated seller ratings, which reflect past transactions and reliability.
Each posting on AppointmentTrader shows you which user submitted it and along with that provides a trackrecord of that user which indicates how much experience
the user has and how many percent of their transactions resulted in them issuing a refund.
If there is no user posting that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
Let's say Peter has a great morning and decides to take his three friends to Rails Steakhouse Montville at 6 PM the same day.
He checks the restaurant's website and sees that no reservations are available. He then looks at the Rails Steakhouse Montville page on AppointmentTrader, but finds that there are no user postings either.
That's where the community-driven bid process comes in.
Peter can place a bid on AppointmentTrader, which serves as a reward for any community member who chooses to work on securing the reservation. AT then notifies experienced users who may be able to help.
Step-by-Step Process
1.) Setting a Reward (Bid)
* AppointmentTrader uses historical data to recommend a reasonable reward amount for securing a reservation - let's say $100.
* Peter really wants to go, so he increases the bid (or reward) to $200.
* At this stage, the reservation does not exist yet.
2.) A Community User Picks Up the Bid
* DistinguishedTree58, an experienced AT user, has a strong track record of successfully securing reservations and low refund requests, they receive a notification about Peter's $200 bid.
* DistinguishedTree58 picks up the bid, meaning they will now work on securing the reservation.
* Peter can now talk to DistinguishedTree58 for any questions Peter may have as DistinguishedTree58 user fills the bid.
3.) Finding the Reservation
* DistinguishedTree58 now uses their connections at Rails Steakhouse Montville to secure the table.
* If they successfully get the 6 PM table for four, Peter receives a confirmation that the reservation has been secured.
* If DistinguishedTree58 fails to secure the reservation, the bid is returned to the pool so another user can try.
4.) Payment & Protection
* Once the reservation is secured, DistinguishedTree58 receives the $200 reward which is credited to DistinguishedTree58's AT balance, where users manage their own funds and can withdraw via available payout options such as bank transfer, PayPal, or Zelle.
* Peter can now enjoy the dinner with his friends at Rails Steakhouse Montville!
* As with all transactions on AT, disputes and no-show fees are handled through the platform's community-driven resolution system. Users with a strong track record are incentivized to fulfill bids successfully, and community members can report issues to maintain trust in the marketplace.
